The CCBE has serious concerns regarding a number of aspects of the European Parliament AFCO draft own-initiative report on the Institutional Framework of the European Union and its interaction with national authorities in the application of Union law, with particular reference to Article 19 TEU (2025/2263(INI)). The report raises important questions concerning the role, independence and institutional autonomy of the Court of Justice, the operation of the preliminary ruling procedure under Article 267 TFEU, the relationship between the Court and national constitutional and supreme courts, and certain aspects of the Court’s internal organisation and judicial activity.
The CCBE therefore considers that particular caution is required in the assessment of the approaches and proposals advanced in the draft report. Any reform in these areas should be based on a clearly identified legal or practical need, remain fully consistent with the framework established by the EU Treaties, and respect judicial independence, the separation of judicial and political functions, effective judicial protection and the uniform application of EU law.